Rankings Towns Reviews About Joe Recommend a Spot Full Rankings
Niagara Region · Ranked by Pizza Review Joe

The best pizza
in Niagara,
ranked.

One guy. One camera. 261 pizzerias across Niagara Falls, St. Catharines, Welland, Fort Erie and the rest of the region, scored on camera so you know exactly where to order tonight.

See the RankingsWatch the Reviews
334Niagara reviews filmed
261Pizzerias ranked
1Honest judge
Niagara Oast House Brewers pizza review
#1 on the list

Niagara Oast House Brewers

Niagara-on-the-Lake, ON · $32.70
9.3SCORE
The Leaderboard

Niagara’s Top 10

Every score comes from a real visit and a real video. No sponsors, no paid placements.

Rank
Pizzeria
Town
Price
Joe’s Score
01
Niagara Oast House BrewersNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$32.70
9.3
02
Antica Pizzeria & RistoranteNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$23.00
9.2
03
Pete's Pizza (Dorchester Rd)Niagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$16.95
9.2
04
The Eager Beaver Eatery and Sports BarNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$13.50
9.2
05
oddBarSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$22.60
9.1
06
Boss PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$31.00
9.1
07
Di's Pizza PiesSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$32.76
9.1
08
Pie Guys PizzeriaNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$17.46
9.1
09
Tailgates Bar & GrillWelland, ON
Welland
—
9.1
10
Volcano PizzeriaThorold, ON
Thorold
$18.07
9.1
See the full rankings
Find Pizza Near You

Best pizza by town

From the Falls to Port Colborne, here’s the top-rated pie in every town Joe has covered.

75 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Niagara Falls

#1: Antica Pizzeria & Ristorante · 9.2
80 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in St. Catharines

#1: oddBar · 9.1
31 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Welland

#1: Tailgates Bar & Grill · 9.1
27 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Fort Erie

#1: Dario's Family Cucina · 8.6
21 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Niagara-on-the-Lake

#1: Niagara Oast House Brewers · 9.3
17 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Port Colborne

#1: The Spot · 8.9
8 pizzerias ranked

Best Pizza in Thorold

#1: Volcano Pizzeria · 9.1
Joe’s Short Lists

Best of Niagara

Best Under $15

Top-rated pies that won’t wreck your wallet.

  1. The Eager Beaver Eatery and Sports Bar9.2
  2. Volcano Pizzeria8.8
  3. The Lock Wood Fired Pizza8.7
See the list

Best in the Falls

The highest scores in Niagara Falls, Ontario.

  1. Antica Pizzeria & Ristorante9.2
  2. Pete's Pizza (Dorchester Rd)9.2
  3. The Eager Beaver Eatery and Sports Bar9.2
See the list

South Niagara Heavyweights

Welland, Port Colborne, Fort Erie and Pelham.

  1. Tailgates Bar & Grill9.1
  2. Luciano's Pizzeria8.9
  3. The Spot8.9
See the list
On Camera

Watch the reviews

All reviews
Antica Pizzeria & Ristorante pizza review
9.2

Antica Pizzeria & Ristorante

Niagara Falls, ON · $23.00
Pete's Pizza (Dorchester Rd) pizza review
9.2

Pete's Pizza (Dorchester Rd)

Niagara Falls, ON · $16.95
The Eager Beaver Eatery and Sports Bar pizza review
9.2

The Eager Beaver Eatery and Sports Bar

Niagara Falls, ON · $13.50
oddBar pizza review
9.1

oddBar

St. Catharines, ON · $22.60
Pizza Review Joe
The judgePizza Review Joe
How Joe Scores

Real visits. Real scores. Every time.

Joe walks in, orders, pays like everyone else, and scores the pie on camera. No free food, no paid placements, no deals with owners.

That’s how a small-town pizzeria can beat the biggest names in Niagara, and why people trust the list.

9+Legendary
8+Go out of your way
7+Solid local slice
Meet Joe
Know a great spot?

Tell Joe where to go next

Got a Niagara pizzeria that deserves a review? Send it in and it could be the next stop on the channel.

Recommend a Pizzeria
Own a pizzeria?

Got reviewed? Claim your listing.

Claim your free page on review.pizza, and see how PizzaPhone answers every call so you never miss an order on a busy Friday night.